Handling misclassified stratification variables in the analysis of randomised trials with continuous outcomes

Lisa N. Yelland, Jennie Louise, Brennan C. Kahan, Tim P. Morris, Katherine J. Lee, Thomas R. Sullivan

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

    2 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Many trials use stratified randomisation, where participants are randomised within strata defined by one or more baseline covariates. While it is important to adjust for stratification variables in the analysis, the appropriate method of adjustment is unclear when stratification variables are affected by misclassification and hence some participants are randomised in the incorrect stratum. We conducted a simulation study to compare methods of adjusting for stratification variables affected by misclassification in the analysis of continuous outcomes when all or only some stratification errors are discovered, and when the treatment effect or treatment-by-covariate interaction effect is of interest. The data were analysed using linear regression with no adjustment, adjustment for the strata used to perform the randomisation (randomisation strata), adjustment for the strata if all errors are corrected (true strata), and adjustment for the strata after some errors are discovered and corrected (updated strata). The unadjusted model performed poorly in all settings. Adjusting for the true strata was optimal, while the relative performance of adjusting for the randomisation strata or the updated strata varied depending on the setting. As the true strata are unlikely to be known with certainty in practice, we recommend using the updated strata for adjustment and performing subgroup analyses, provided the discovery of errors is unlikely to depend on treatment group, as expected in blinded trials. Greater transparency is needed in the reporting of stratification errors and how they were addressed in the analysis.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)3529-3546
    Number of pages18
    JournalStatistics in Medicine
    Volume42
    Issue number19
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished or Issued - 30 Aug 2023

    Keywords

    • covariate misclassification
    • covariate-adaptive randomisation
    • randomisation error
    • stratification error
    • stratified randomisation

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Epidemiology
    • Statistics and Probability

    Cite this